Grilled Cheddar Sandwich with Pears and Pecans

DISH: Grilled Cheddar Sandwich with Pears and Pecans
TYPE: Weekday Lunch
MAIN INGREDIENTS: Homemade Bread, Cheese, Pears

I adore grilled cheese by whatever name: quesadilla, panini, pizza (ok, maybe that last one’s a stretch). It is practically in my blood, at least the blood from my mother’s side. My father’s side almost universally detests cheese. But my maternal grandparents, as I understand it, when they went to Paris for the first time fell in love with Croque Monsieurs. They ordered them at a bistro for lunch and were blown away. At all the Parisian meals that followed that one, they were unable to order anything but this fancy grilled cheese sandwich. They ate Croque Monsieur after Croque Monsieur–my heaven.

Though I am never dissatisfied with the classic, sprucing up grilled cheese is a worthwhile endeavor in my book. It’s not to prevent boredom, exactly. It’s for fun, for variety. Depending on what ingredients you add, you can even occasionally nudge the grilled cheese ever so slightly in the direction of healthful. Phoebe’s been known to add sauteed mushrooms to her grilled cheese, but in this sandwich I went a route she never would: I used pears.

We first made these sweetened, roasted pears for a salad at a lunch we catered. On top of mixed greens, with toasted pecans and cider vinaigrette, they were phenomenal. I figured they’d provide a similar texture and taste to this grilled cheese sandwich. Their sweetness was offset by a slather of good mustard, a sprinkling of pecans, and, of course, cheese–sharp white cheddar. On the other hand, the homemade egg bread I made several loaves of the first week in January, with its honeyed, dense crumb, sort of catered to the pears.

In a month when we normally revert to eating salads and soups, this grilled cheese is a wonderful counterpoint. It might perhaps even be enjoyed alongside one of the aforementioned dishes. Half a sandwich and a bowl of soup has got to be one of the best-ever winter lunches.

From my kitchen, eating the best grilled cheese sandwiches for lunch, to yours,



Grilled Cheddar Sandwich with Roasted Pear and Pecans
Makes 2 sandwiches


1 tablespoon butter, melted
1 teaspoon sugar
pinch cinnamon
Kosher salt
1 Bosc pear, quartered, cored, and cut into ¼-inch thick slices
10 pecan halves
2 teaspoons whole grain mustard
1 teaspoon honey
pinch cayenne
4 slices good egg bread, toasted
3 ounces sharp cheddar, grated (about 2/3 cup)

Preheat the oven to 375°F. Combine the melted butter with the sugar, cinnamon, and a pinch of salt. Add the pears and pecans and toss to coat. Arrange them on a parchment-lined baking sheet. Bake for 10 minutes, then remove the pecans and bake the pears for 5 minutes more. Leave the oven on. When the pecans are cool enough to handle, chop them coarsely.

Stir together the mustard, honey, and a pinch of cayenne. Place two slice of bread on a greased baking sheet, then spread each with half the mustard mixture. Top each with two layers of pears, then divide the cheddar between the two. Bake for 5-8 minutes, until the cheese is melted.

Remove from the oven and sprinkle half the pecans over each sandwich. Top with the remaining two slices of bread, and carefully flip the sandwiches. Bake for another 3-5 minutes.

Cut each sandwich in half and serve.


  1. I love pears, honey and cheese together! Crunchy pecans and a little bit of heat from the cayenne are strokes of genius – definitely trying this one out! Love the new site, especially the cute food art!

  2. I love pears, honey and cheese together! Crunchy pecans and a little bit of heat from the cayenne are strokes of genius – definitely trying this one out! Love the new site, especially the cute food art!

  3. that sounds amazingly delicious. i LOVE pears, especially in sweet-salty combinations (and, obviously, covered in cheese). the new site looks lovely! you ladies do a beautiful job — please know that it is very much appreciated.

  4. I LOVE LOVE LOVE the new site. Beautiful, navigable and all around fun! So excited to catch up in person soon! 🙂 xoxo

  5. This sandwich looks so great! Do you also have a recipe for the cider vinaigrette please? Did you put any cheese in the salad when you made it? I was thinking maybe a blue cheese would be good with it………

  6. Grilled cheese sandwich upgrade! (now all I need is a good soup to accompany it… I’ll probably find one through your list sooner or later!)

    If I may ask, what kind of egg bread do you recommend?

    – Vanessa
    Project Zen

  7. I adapted this last night for a quick and easy dinner. I sauteed under-ripe D’anjou pears in a little oil. Once they were softened, I added a little maple syrup and a few pecans (already toasted because that’s a staple I keep in my freezer) and cooked until the syrup had caramelized the pears. I melted parmesan cheese on top of a piece of country-bread toast (have you tried the bread from Almondine–it’s outstanding), and put the pears and pecans on top. Delicious! Thanks for the inspiration.

    Love the new site and I’m looking forward to your book.

  8. Made this today with oatmeal bread and sharp provolone in place of egg bread and cheddar. The first sandwich was delicious at lunch; the second was even better at dinner, after I reheated it wrapped in foil for 20 minutes at 375 degrees. This is the first recipe I’ve tried from your site, and I suspect it is going to be the first of many.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *